Current Members in Creel Survey (Please include all species caught)
Displaying entries 1 - 25 of 875
Sort by Date  or  Name





Date December 7, 2017
Name Jon Niebauer
Email Bauer12284@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2 Rainbows, one 11" and one 12". Another 14-ish" got off at the net
Home City/ State Fishers, In
Date & Hrs Fished 12/03/2017 fished from noon to 4
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 160 miles round trip, 0$ spent
Comments Tried small black midges, scuds, SJ worm, even real eggs/spawn bags- all usually produce efficiently. Nothing worked. Put on a large prince nymph and had 2 fish within 20 min. Water was murky, should have gone big and meaty right off the bat. Wonderful December day in the 60's! Love this stream!




Date October 2, 2017
Name Patrick Goddard
Email ppg359@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 14/5-10"/rainbow trout, 2/10"/Brown trout, 1/18"/catfish, and 1 /20"/whitefish?
Home City/ State Cincinnati/OH
Date & Hrs Fished September 30th, fished for 4 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 100 miles and $20 spent
Comments Had a great morning using a heavy pheasant tail nymph pattern and a black midge




Date September 5, 2017
Name Patrick Goddard
Email ppg359@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 4 small (4", 6", 6", 8") rainbow
Home City/ State Cincinnati/OH
Date & Hrs Fished 9/4/2017, 5 hours, 730-1230
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 90 miles and $25 in gas and food
Comments Access was great, there seemed to be a lot of sediment in the streambed (steps prouced thick chocolate milk-like clouds). This could possibly be from from the unstabilized open earth channel below the dam. Three of the fish were stockers and the one 4" fish seemed to be a naturally reproduced one. It had pronounced visible spots and better coloration than the others.




Date June 12, 2017
Name jeff maryanski
Email halliard@earthlink.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 12419 branford st.
Home City/ State carmel
Date & Hrs Fished in
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent $o 175 miles
Comments 2 brown trout on soft hackle dropper from an adams dry. 1 20 in. 1 14 in. Wow!




Date June 6, 2017
Name Jason Burdorff
Email jason.burdorff@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2 brown trout 10-12"
Home City/ State Cincinnati, OH
Date & Hrs Fished 6/03/2017 7:30AM - noon
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 93 miles
Comments This was my first time fishing at Brookville. fish were caught on san juan worm and medium size hare's ear.




Date November 19, 2016
Name Jared Horvath
Email shadowhorvath@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 4 Brown Trout; 10"to 16"
Home City/ State Brookville, Ohio
Date & Hrs Fished 11/6/2016; 5 hrs
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 120 Miles; $0
Comments Great trout stream. Had an awesome time! Thanks for all that you do for this trout fishery.




Date August 28, 2016
Name Ian Franke
Email ikfranke@fuse.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 3/11-16"/ Rainbow and browns
Home City/ State CINCINNATI
Date & Hrs Fished 8-27 4 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 76/$10
Comments Caught al three fish on 3 different methods. First brown on nymph, rainbow on EHC, and 16" brown swinging a wooly bugger late. Also hooked and missed several other fish nymphing. Small Trico hatch in progress, but couldnt hook any of the few risers. Tough conditions with low, clear water.




Date July 31, 2016
Name Bill
Email williamwojcieszek@yahoo.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1 Brown; 7 Rainbows; All 12-15"
Home City/ State Indianapolis, IN
Date & Hrs Fished July 29th; 7 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent n/a
Comments Best fishing was from 7am - 1030am. Midge then Trico hatch. Fish were eating mostly emerges (you could see the backs and tails breaking the surface, not their noses). I used a seine to sample bugs; the naturals were basically a size 30/32. I was able to fool a few of them on a size 26 midge emerger.




Date July 25, 2016
Name Ashley
Email ashley.sperz@yahoo.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2/17-19in/Rainbow
Home City/ State Louisville, KY
Date & Hrs Fished 7-24-16/8am-11am
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 120 miles
Comments New to sport of fly fishing, was there 3hrs, after setup and getting in fished for a solid hour. Caught my first trout - it was real fun.




Date June 7, 2016
Name Jim Smith
Email smith.jim805@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2/13/trout
Home City/ State Loveland/Ohio
Date & Hrs Fished 6/4& 3
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 100 & 10
Comments Fishing was a bit slow. Eager fish found upstream of the the bridge nearest the dam.




Date May 30, 2016
Name Jim Smith
Email smith.jim805@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 5/13 inch/rainbow
Home City/ State Loveland/oh
Date & Hrs Fished 5/29 & 4
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 100/$20
Comments Had to hunt a little this time. Deeper holes and faster water held fish. Fish getting more selective too.




Date May 22, 2016
Name Jim Smith
Email smith.jim805@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 20/14 inch plus/trout
Home City/ State Loveland/Ohio
Date & Hrs Fished 5/22 & 5
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 100 & $20
Comments Plenty of fat rainbows and one nice 16 inch brown.




Date May 15, 2016
Name Jim Smith
Email smith.jim805@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 5/13/trout
Home City/ State Loveland/Ohio
Date & Hrs Fished 5-15/3 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 100 & $20
Comments Nice afternoon at Brookville tailwater. Landed 5 - 3 healthy rainbows and a recent stocker brown...But one brown was a 16" holdover with blue gill plates, just a beautiful fish. It slammed a tiny #22 nymph.




Date May 15, 2016
Name Jeff georgin
Email Jsgeorgin@fuse.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 21 browns,3 rainbows, 1 smallmouth,1 chub some of the browns were nice fat 13-14" holdovers
Home City/ State Cincinnati
Date & Hrs Fished 5-13. 5 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 80 miles $30
Comments Most fish taken on nymphs even the smallmouth




Date April 17, 2016
Name Tom Joyner
Email Tom@joynerhomesonline.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 6 Browns 12-16"
Home City/ State Greenfield, IN
Date & Hrs Fished 04/15/16 11-4pm
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 120 miles
Comments Not stocked yet... The holdover browns were definately biting though!




Date April 10, 2016
Name Tom Joyner
Email Tom@joynerhomesonline.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2/12"/brown
Home City/ State Greenfield, in
Date & Hrs Fished 3/28/16
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent $20
Comments Lots of dead walleye floating in the water???




Date December 15, 2015
Name Jack Harford
Email jharford.indy@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1 Brown 13"
Home City/ State Indianapolis
Date & Hrs Fished 13-Dec-15 1.5 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 160 miles 0 spent
Comments Albino Grandpa's Chickenhawk fly




Date September 10, 2015
Name Tom Joyner
Email Tom@joynerhomesonline.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 12/12"-18"/3bows-9brwn
Home City/ State Greenfield, IN
Date & Hrs Fished 09/10/15- 9am-1pm
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 120
Comments Epic day! Caught 10 in less than in houramd then the water dropped a foot and the bite cooled off.




Date September 7, 2015
Name John Evans
Email Evans.864@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 4 Browns. Three 12 inches. One 18 inches
Home City/ State Columbus, Oh
Date & Hrs Fished 9/6/2016 - 5 hrs
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 250 miles - $20
Comments Water was low and clear but the fish were fairly active given the heat. They were taking sz 20 black zebra midge. Some luck with red ants on top.




Date August 29, 2015
Name Michael F
Email titanlor@hotmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish One 14 inch Brown Trout, and two 12 inch brown trout
Home City/ State Fairfield/OH
Date & Hrs Fished 8/28/15 10 a.m. - 1 p.m.
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 82 $14
Comments Water level 3.05, mostly sunny, fished above and below SR 252 bridge. Success with a size 16 Tellico nymph and a size 14 Yellow Sulfur dry fly. Saw two other fishermen.




Date June 26, 2015
Name John oerter
Email Johnoerter@mindspring.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 5- 4 browns big = 16". 1rainbow
Home City/ State Lvl. Ky
Date & Hrs Fished 26th. 5 hrs
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 260 miles. $10
Comments App said 3.5'. Had to pick around the edges.




Date June 15, 2015
Name Jeff Georgin
Email jseorgin@fuse.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 3 Browns, 1 rainbow, 3 crappies, 1 largemouth & an 18" smallmouth all on streamers
Home City/ State Cincinnati
Date & Hrs Fished 6-10 7 hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 80 miles $25
Comments Fish were not interested in nymphs for a change but chased streamers consistently.




Date May 30, 2015
Name Tom Joyber
Email Tom@joynerhomesonline.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 7/10-12"/browns
Home City/ State Greenfield, IN
Date & Hrs Fished 5/29/15-7am-2pm
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 120 miles
Comments Nice day. Browns were hitting #22 zebra midges




Date May 27, 2015
Name Jeff georgin
Email Jsgeorgin@fuse.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 5 rainbows 4 Browns biggest 14"
Home City/ State Cincinnati
Date & Hrs Fished 5-27 five hours
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent 80 miles $25
Comments Fish hit a variety of flies. Half caught on streamers. Pretty day on the BTW




Date May 21, 2015
Name Jay Roberts
Email roberja@earlham.edu
Number/Size/Type of Fish 10+ Browns/ 8-10"
Home City/ State Richmond
Date & Hrs Fished Indiana (IN)
Roundtrip Miles & $ Spent United States
Comments Lots of activity with recently stocked browns. They were hitting both dry flies on the top and nymphs. Had at least one bigger one on but lost it. The great blue heron fishing next to me was waiting to take over the pool...