Current Members in Creel Survey (Please include all species caught)
Displaying entries 1 - 25 of 967
Sort by Date  or  Name



Date January 14, 2026
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1/12in/Trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 1/13/26 5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temp 40F. Was checked by DNR today.



Date December 28, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2/7-10/trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 12/27/25 4.5 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments



Date December 28, 2025
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 7- 8-12in rainbows
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 12/27. 3 hrs
Where did you fish? United States
Comments



Date December 26, 2025
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 7-8-12 in rainbows
Home City/State Bloomington,IN
Date & Hrs Fished 12/25 4 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments



Date December 11, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 0/0/trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 12/9/25 3hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temp 38F. Went to triangle falls first but the water was extremely roiled up. Then went to the mill and the water was clear. Still having problems connecting with fish.



Date December 6, 2025
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 8/8-12 in. / rainbows
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 12/6. 2.5 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments



Date December 2, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 0/0/trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 12/1/25 3hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temp 34 F. Stream was running clear. I'm not having much success this year so far.



Date November 29, 2025
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 14/8-12in. /rainbows
Home City/State Bloomington/IN
Date & Hrs Fished 11/28/25
Where did you fish? Sugarcreek
Comments



Date November 22, 2025
Name David
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2/12in/rainbow trout
Home City/State
Date & Hrs Fished 11/22/2025 - 2.5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Caught two trout in the morning hours on a size 12 pheasant tail, then a size 2 sparkle minnow (which I was surprised they were able to hit a size 2 so well) only fished one hole due to lack of time, but I’m sure there were others to be caught



Date November 21, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 0/0/trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 11/20/25 4hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temp 49F Fishing at 460 cfs is challenging. Talked to 1 other person fishing and they reported 0 trout caught.



Date November 17, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1/10in/Trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 11/16/25 6 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temperature 52 F. Creek is very low and clear. A lot of sediment has filled in some areas. I met 1 person on the creek and they reported catching 4 trout. IF you are reading this why aren't you submitting creel reports?



Date May 6, 2025
Name nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1/13in/Trout
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 4/29/25 3.5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water was high, temp 68F



Date April 19, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 9/4-9in/Bluegill, SMB, Rock bass
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 4/18/25 4.5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Saw two others fishing today Water was slightly stained temp was 59F



Date April 15, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1/12in/Sucker
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 4/14/25 2.5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Sucker had lamprey wound on it's side near the tail. Water was cloudy and high temp 59F



Date March 5, 2025
Name Nick
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1 rainbow 12in
Home City/State Seymour
Date & Hrs Fished 3/4/25 2.5hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments Water temp 44F. Some stoneflies hatching out



Date March 1, 2025
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 4 rainbow. 12 -15 in.
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 3/1/25. 3 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments These fish were fat and healthy.



Date December 22, 2024
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 11 rainbow 8-15 in.
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 12/22. 3 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments I'll say it again. These fish seem bigger and fatter than last year.



Date December 8, 2024
Name Garrett Henry
Email G7henry@gmail.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish Brown/ rainbow
Home City/State Indianapolis IN
Date & Hrs Fished 12-8-24 2hrs
Where did you fish? Eagle creek, Zionsville
Comments Love the stocking every year. Can't wait to try sugar creek next.



Date November 29, 2024
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 5 rainbow. 8-14 inches
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 11/29. 3 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments Very cold. Tough bite.



Date November 26, 2024
Name Dan Hackleberry
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 1/8"/chubsucker
Home City/State Indianapolis
Date & Hrs Fished 11/26/24
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek
Comments spinning gear, no luck at the mill wall with rooster tails. chubsucker on triangle road. two others wading there. no catches but many bites on a small crankbait near hospital bridge



Date November 26, 2024
Name Todd Settle
Email zionsvillein@ameritech.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish 20 plus
Home City/State Zionsville, IN
Date & Hrs Fished 11/24/24 3 hours
Where did you fish? Eagle Creek
Comments Very good day saw 10 other anglers on the creek



Date November 26, 2024
Name Todd W Settle
Email zionsvillein@ameritech.net
Number/Size/Type of Fish alot of bows
Home City/State Zionsville
Date & Hrs Fished 11/24/24 3 hours
Where did you fish? Eagle Creek
Comments Very good day saw 10 other anglers on the creek



Date November 25, 2024
Name Nolan Smith
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 10 Rainbow Trout
Home City/State Indianapolis
Date & Hrs Fished 11/24 - 4 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek Edinburgh
Comments Started at the Falls. Water temp was 48'F and clear. The fish don't seem to be in the same position as last year in this spot. Was definitely a slower part of my day. Moved to the Mill. Fished both sides below of the higher riffle (were wall used to be) and was able to pickup fish. Used beaded salmon pink egg. Was also able to get one fish above the riffle. Agree that the fish are bigger this year. A couple fish gave a surprisingly good fight.



Date November 22, 2024
Name Eric Bass
Email
Number/Size/Type of Fish 18 rainbow 8-18 inches
Home City/State Bloomington
Date & Hrs Fished 11/22/24. 5 hrs
Where did you fish? Sugar creek
Comments These fish seam bigger and healthier than the ones stocked last year. My average size today 14-16 inches. Measured biggest at 18 in.



Date November 18, 2024
Name Nolan Smith
Email smithnolan@me.com
Number/Size/Type of Fish 2 Rainbow Trout; 12 - 14 inches
Home City/State Indianapolis, IN
Date & Hrs Fished 11/16/24; 3 hrs in the afternoon
Where did you fish? Sugar Creek (Edinburgh)
Comments The water levels were high and the water was murky. Water temp was 54'F. Initially tried the Falls but had no luck. Water was moving fast. Then went to the Mill. Caught my fish on a squirmy worm.